Skip to main content
Bulletin Q&A

NIW or EB-1A: Choosing a Self-Filed Green Card, and How the Dates and Evidence Differ (November 2026)

Back to Bulletin Q&A

NIW (national interest waiver) and EB-1A (extraordinary ability) are both green card petitions you can file yourself, with no employer and no PERM (labor certification), and you can file the I-140 (the immigrant petition form) on your own. But the two categories ask you to prove different things, and their dates are far apart: in the Department of State's November 2026 bulletin, EB-1 (first preference) is current for the all-chargeability column, while EB-2 (second preference, advanced degree professionals), where NIW sits, runs to April 1, 2025.

If you are asking "should I file an NIW or an EB-1A," this article does not decide for you. It sets out what the official documents say: what each category has to prove, what to prepare for each, what the dates and reviews look like right now, and a few questions you can answer yourself.

The short answer first: an NIW asks "is what you plan to do valuable enough to the United States, and are you the right person to do it"; an EB-1A asks "are you already at the very top of your field." The first looks at what you intend to do, and the second mainly looks at what you have already done. A PhD does not automatically get you either one, and the USCIS Policy Manual says so for both categories.

Today's immigration updateUSCIS 生物信息(指纹)预约去不了,能改期吗?One a day, in Chinese, with the official source

01 What does each category have to prove?

Here is a side-by-side table first, then each one in turn.

NIW (national interest waiver, EB-2)EB-1A (extraordinary ability, EB-1)
The core thing to proveYour endeavor has substantial merit and national importance; you are well positioned to advance it; waiving the labor certification benefits the United StatesYou have sustained national or international acclaim and are among the small percentage at the very top of the field
Looks mainly atWhat you plan to do, and why you are the right personWhat you have already done
How the bar is writtenThree conditions (the Dhanasar three prongs)One major one-time achievement, or at least three of ten criteria, followed by an overall judgment
Employer neededNoNo
Labor certification (PERM)WaivedNot required
A degree needed firstAn advanced degree, or exceptional abilityThe regulation has no degree requirement

02 What are the NIW "three prongs"?

Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5 of the USCIS Policy Manual says an NIW can be approved only if all three of the following are met (the standard from Matter of Dhanasar): Policy Manual

  1. The endeavor you propose has substantial merit and national importance.
  2. You are well positioned to advance it.
  3. On balance, it would benefit the United States to waive the job offer and the labor certification.

In plain words, a few details are the ones people most often miss:

  • "Endeavor" is much more specific than "occupation." The Policy Manual's example: "engineer" is an occupation. What you have to describe is which area of engineering and which projects, with what goals, and not just a list of what an engineer normally does.
  • Benefit to one employer is not enough. The manual says that benefit falling on a single employer, even one with a national footprint, is not sufficient to show national importance. You need to show broader effects on a field, a region or the public.
  • "There is a shortage in this occupation" is not enough on its own. The manual also says that evidence of a national labor shortage in the occupation cannot by itself satisfy the third prong.
  • The second prong is about you. The manual lists many kinds of evidence: degrees, patents, citation records, proof that others use your work, letters from experts, letters from investors or customers, a plan for the work, and more. It also says this is not a checklist: no single item is required, and no single item is enough.

03 What does the EB-1A "three of ten" mean?

The EB-1A rule is in 8 CFR 204.5(h). The Policy Manual (Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2) splits the review into two steps: Policy Manual

  • Step one: does the evidence you submitted meet the regulation? Either one major one-time achievement (an internationally recognized award at the level of a Nobel Prize), or at least three of the ten types of evidence.
  • Step two: the overall judgment. All the evidence is weighed together to decide whether you are among the small percentage at the very top of the field, with sustained national or international acclaim.

The ten types of evidence (8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)) are:

  1. Nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards
  2. Membership in associations that require outstanding achievement
  3. Published material about you and your work in professional or major media
  4. Your participation as a judge of the work of others
  5. Original contributions of major significance
  6. Authorship of scholarly articles
  7. Display of your work at exhibitions or showcases
  8. A leading or critical role for organizations with a distinguished reputation
  9. A high salary or other high remuneration compared with others in the field
  10. Commercial success in the performing arts

Two points to keep in mind:

  • Meeting three is only the first step. The second step is the overall judgment. The manual says an officer cannot deny a petition just because one kind of evidence is missing, but all the evidence is weighed together to see whether you are really at the top.
  • Each type has a quality bar too. For the first, for example, the manual says the award must be recognized nationally or internationally, and an award open only to people in one locality, one employer or one school may not be recognized enough.

04 How far apart are the dates and the reviews in November 2026?

By the Department of State's November 2026 bulletin (Chart A, Final Action Date):

ColumnEB-1 (EB-1A)EB-2 (NIW)
All chargeabilityC, current2025-04-01
Mainland China2023-08-012021-10-01
India2023-02-012013-11-01

This month USCIS has employment-based applicants use Chart B to file the I-485 (the green card application form): EB-1 all chargeability is C, EB-2 all chargeability is 2026-03-15, and EB-2 mainland China is 2023-01-01 (USCIS page, checked on November 18, 2026). The detail for each column is in this bulletin analysis.

On the review side, from USCIS's fiscal year 2026 third-quarter (April to June) I-140 table: the EB-1A approval rate was 32.2% and the NIW rate was 55.3%; NIW had 96,297 cases pending at the end of the quarter. The EB-1A approval rate has fallen for eight straight quarters, while NIW fell and then steadied. The numbers and the method are in this article.

Two things to note:

  • An approval rate is not your probability. It is the share of approvals among approvals and denials for the whole category in that quarter, and it cannot be read as your own chance.
  • The dates and the review are two separate queues. EB-1A all chargeability has no queue, but the I-140 approval rate is falling. The NIW approval rate is recovering, but the backlog is large and the dates are longer. You cannot say which path is "faster" from one number.

05 How do you choose? Answer these five questions first

These cannot replace an attorney's judgment, but they can help you see where you stand:

  1. In your materials, is there more weight on "what you have already done" or on "what you plan to do"? The first leans EB-1A, and the second leans NIW.
  2. Can you produce three of the ten types of evidence? If so, you can talk about the first step of EB-1A. If not, do not treat EB-1A as your main route yet.
  3. Can you say in a sentence or two what specific thing you will do and why it matters to the United States? Not being able to is the most common sticking point for an NIW.
  4. Do you have an advanced degree or exceptional ability? An NIW needs EB-2 eligibility first. The EB-1A regulation has no degree requirement and looks at the ten types of evidence above.
  5. Where were you born? For people born in mainland China or India, the EB-1 and EB-2 dates are clearly far apart (see the table above). That affects when you can file the I-485, but it cannot decide on its own which to choose.

06 Can you file both?

The regulation addresses this situation. 8 CFR 204.5(e)(1) says that when a person has several approved first, second or third preference petitions, the earliest priority date applies. eCFR That means that, under the law, one person can hold more than one I-140.

But this is a strategy question and not an eligibility question: each petition needs its own materials, will be reviewed on its own, and carries its own risk. Whether to file both at once, and which first, has to be decided with an attorney according to your own materials. We give no advice on that here.

07 What can you do now?

  • Evaluate it yourself first: list your materials against each side's checklist and see which side is empty and which is solid.
  • Not decided yet: the priority date starts the day you file the I-140, so filing earlier makes the date earlier. But read literally, if the filing is returned because materials are missing or the fee is wrong, that day may not count. Both matter: do not file something that is not ready just to grab a date.
  • Approved and changing the direction of your work: see this case article.
  • EB-1 mainland China: when the date has come up but you are stuck at "no numbers," see this case article.
Subscribe to bulletin and policy updates

visa-updates|Tell me when EB-1 and EB-2 dates move

One email each month when the bulletin lands. Unsubscribe anytime.

08 Should you talk to an attorney?

Both categories are self-filed, so no employer or HR is there to check how the materials are organized or how the evidence maps to the regulation. If you want an immigration attorney who focuses on EB-1A and NIW to look at whether your materials are enough, an evaluation first is a reasonable step before deciding which path to take.

Sources

  • USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5 (EB-2 and the national interest waiver) and Chapter 2 (EB-1A extraordinary ability), version current as of October 27, 2026: Chapter 5, Chapter 2.
  • 8 CFR 204.5(h) (the ten types of EB-1A evidence) and 204.5(e) (retention of priority dates): eCFR.
  • Department of State, Visa Bulletin for November 2026; USCIS, Adjustment of Status Filing Charts (checked on November 18, 2026): Department of State bulletin.
  • USCIS I-140 quarterly report, fiscal year 2026 third quarter (released September 8, 2026); the numbers and method are in this article.

This article is based on public government documents. It is for general information only and is not legal advice. We are not a law firm. Rules change, so consult an immigration attorney before making a decision.

Written from public government data and announcements. For reference only — this is not legal advice. We are not a law firm. Immigration rules change; consult an immigration attorney before acting.